Paul Goulter, Chief Executive
NZNO Tōpūtanga Tapuhi Kaitiaki o Aotearoa
Kia ora tātou,
Ngā mihi nui kia koutou katua
Ko Paul Goulter taku ingoa
Ko au te tamuaki o te
Tapo tanga Tapui kaitiaki o Aotearoa
It is a privilege to stand here and address you. It’s our first chance to get together kanohi ki te kanohi.
This is our first chance as a group to confront our situation and address what needs to be done – nurses, midwives, HCAs, care and support workers, Māori and Iwi – we all have this in front of us
But firstly, a tribute to you all. You are the living face of the frontline. You stood firm against Covid, you took on risks and you met your professional obligations.
And the New Zealand public love you for it.
But what my speech will be about is the future – what we need to do together, in our union to take on the biggest nursing crisis we have faced.
Because we find ourselves in the middle of that nursing crisis, with a govt that is struggling to fix it.
So we NZNO will drive the fixing it and we will be relentless in doing so.
So what is our situation?
- we don’t recruit and train enough nurses
- we don’t retain enough nurses in the service; and
- the jobs are increasingly not good jobs.
We are more than 4000 nurses short. Our workforce is aging, our nurses are leaving – not just overseas but leaving the profession – nurses have simply had enough!
Our nursing numbers are propped up by immigration – we have the highest number of immigrant nurses in the OECD 26 percent in 2019 (and more now). Switzerland is just behind us then a significant drop to Australia at 18% then basically everyone else is in single figures.
Of course, we welcome our nurse colleagues from overseas but fundamentally this country has to take responsibility for recruiting and training its own.
And it has failed and continues to fail to do this – instead relying on immigration to prop up failed workforce strategies.
Do you know what they call their nursing workforce strategies? The nursing pipeline – there is even a Nursing Pipeline work group – well you can guess what I think when I think of a pipeline – it’s an insult to the profession and its contribution.
We simply do not have enough students going into training, they struggle to stay in training and come out of training with huge debts. For Māori nurses – the numbers are way worse and attrition of Māori nursing students is much higher.
Fundamentally there are not enough nurses and the ones who remain here are being flogged to death. A fact that the public seem to know but our political leaders seem unable to respond to.
Instead in the last Budget, the Government committed billions for the change from DHBs to Te Whatu Ora and Te Aka Whai Ora but hardly a cent more for the frontline work force – nurses, doctors and allied health.
So what do we struggle with? We struggle:
- to get paid properly
- to have safe and health workplaces
- with getting nursing students into education and training
- with a system that relies on immigration but won’t put nurses on the green list (as doctors are)
- with a system that does not recognise and respond to the needs of Māori health and Māori nurses.
This is a crisis – the Minister can call it whatever he likes but it is and remains a crisis. You know it’s a crisis because daily you live it in your workplaces
And if we standby and let it run without fighting for the changes we need then we all – as NZNO, as member leaders – we all stand condemned.
We came to this conference to learn, to recharge, meet old friends but you also came here to do something about that crisis
And you came here to lead your part of NZNO – in whatever roles you have – to make those changes.
This nursing workforce crisis is not new – it predates Covid, it worsened during Covid and it will continue post Covid.
And it has a face, a human face, your face and the faces of the nurses you represent.
And they are all saying – ‘enough’.
And they are challenging their union and its leadership to get out there and advocate their cause and organise.
That is why we have Maranga Mai! Every nurse, everywhere – out there and active
It’s simply not good enough be a bunch of dispersed voices complaining about their situation.
As a union we need to join up those voices, directing and focusing them around the key Maranga Mai! messages and fixes; and then
And then we need to get out there, on the streets organising and fighting for our fixes.
I congratulate those of you who have been active in the workplace, in your sectors and in the public.
- Our delegates
- Our HSRs
- Our regional councillors and college and sections leaders
- Our aged and retirement care nurses and care workers who rallied back in May around the country for just funding
- Our primary healthcare colleagues who rallied two weeks ago for pay parity
- Our Māori colleagues who daily confront the injustices of our existing health system
- And if I have forgotten anyone – sorry about that and let’s give them a big clap as well!
Before I go any further I want to talk about a couple of areas that effect everyone in this conference – pay equity and pay parity.
It is now well known that our hospital nurses made it quite clear that despite around six years of waiting, the pay equity proposals emerging from the pay equity process were not good enough.
So you spoke up and it was stopped. It was stopped because:
- it didn’t provide full back pay to 2019 despite this being promised
- it didn’t address gender discrepancies across the board
- it didn’t provide for a mechanism of review that ensured the gender discrimination did not re-emerge later down the road.
And then our members said – quite correctly – take it to the Employment Relations Authority and the Employment Court and get it sorted – get the rates arbitrated by an independent ERA member and the back pay by the Employment Court.
So we are in the Employment Court arguing that the government was obliged to pay full back pay to 2019; and
We are in the ERA saying that all the proposed rates need to be reviewed and reset higher due to flawed bargaining processes forced by the Crown.
And by the way – on the backpay lets here what our Minister said and what the DHB employers said about back pay
AL – There would be back pay to the agreed starting point of December 31 2019. The government had not considered any further back pay.
DHB – Settling the pay equity claim comes with a commitment to backdate any increase to 31 December 2019 and the DHBs are asking that’s taken into consideration in this pay round
And what has been the response from the Minister when we lodged with the ERA –
Nurses in hospitals, right now, would be on base incomes between $10,000 and $12,000 a year more had the Nurses Organisation not blocked a pay equity deal they signed up to in December last year. You can understand that I find the Nurses Organisation talking with a forked tongue on many issues,
And if that is not good enough the Crown goes further and lodges a claim for a $20,000 penalty for a breach of good faith because we stopped the process.
Minister – we say there was no deal. An agreement in principle is not a contract. Here is the final draft document they were asking you to vote on – you cannot see it from this distance but:
- it has ‘draft’ all over it
- changes were still being tracked in and
- none of the various government authorities expected to have signed it before you voted on it had done so.
And the Minister still says we had welched on the deal.
No, there was no deal and yes we are using your governments Equal Pay Act to resolve it
Our nurses need that money. And we must recognise our midwives are lining up behind this process as their pay equity process has also stalled awaiting resolution of the nurses’ issues.
Its scandalous that on one hand the government acknowledges the long-standing gender discrimination and on the other refuses to pay out.
In saying ‘no’ you have shown the public and the government, NZNO will no longer be pushed around.
It signals that time is over, that things have changed
That’s Maranga Mai! – Rise Up!
And of course, any discussion of pay equity leads directly to pay parity
And that is the struggle our nurses outside of the hospitals are having to even receive the current DHB rates – in ARC, primary and community health, Māori and Iwi providers, Pasifika, Plunket and all our other frontline areas, let alone any pay equity enhanced rates.
And the very time when the public and NZNO and nurses and doctors everywhere are crying out for funding at the frontline – in the last Budget our govt delivered basically nothing for that frontline
What were they thinking?
Now the future
Firstly – in hospitals –
We must fix this winter payments debacle. The decision by TWO to unilaterally introduce a series of payments with no negotiation with NZNO is:
- a danger to health and safety as it encourages already fatigued nurses to work on
- It discriminates between doctors and nurses on the payments, and in our view
- It breaches good faith and the Act.
We have already heard from members who are taking a stand on this winter payments programme and have been calling on NZNO to support those members.
And so today we are calling on Te Whatu Ora to immediately enter into negotiations to change the current programme that ends on 30 September and any new replacement programme.
And if they don’t satisfactorily conclude those negotiations then we call on our members in the week of Monday 3 October till Sunday, 9 October to work only contracted hours.
It is a health and safety issue and it’s a respect issue.
TWO needs face up to their obligations:
- under the ERA,
- under the H&S Act and
- in good faith.
And negotiate safe arrangements with NZNO that are nationally consistent and are consistent with what doctors get.
Can we do that?
Should we do that?
Secondly, right around the corner is the bargaining for new Te Whatu Ora CA to replace the DHB MECA which expires on 31 October
We have been planning this campaign for some time and are ready to launch.
Apart from other claims to be raised by members, we will focus on –
- An acceptable pay increase in line with the rise in cost of living – to be either delivered through the current negotiations between the govt and the public sector unions – called a Public Sector Pay Adjustment; or
- Through direct bargaining across the table
- We want to give teeth to what is called Safe Staffing. As the Ministerial review showed (but strangely did not conclude) CCDM is not working for nurses atb. Just like the Aussie nursing unions we want ratios – mandated staffing levels along with a CCDM generated overlay on top of those levels as well as a cultural overlay for Māori nurses working with Māori. We want the ratios regulated but we cannot wait for legislation so we are going after them in our CA negotiations; and
- We want expanded health and safety rights and protections. Our nursing crisis is a health and safety crisis for staff and patients alike. We need to use and expand on the existing rights and protections to give force to correcting unsafe workplaces – and for those of you already doing that – congratulations
- We have established escalation pathways to escalate these health and safety issues including violence in the workplace. We need to be prepared to take advantage of our rights under the Act – issuing PINS, standing up against unacceptable management behaviour, moving to cease work orders and fundamentally be prepared to use the legal protections of the Act to refuse unsafe work if not satisfactorily addressed.
- The situation is so bad there is nothing left to do than take this ramped up stance and support our HSRs and delegates who lead this. What is called a staffing crisis is in fact a health and safety crisis.
- And this means putting intense pressure on Te Whatu Ora through exercising our H&S Rights and protections in this bargaining campaign to demonstrate why we need extended those extended rights in our new CA. H&S is our number one risk, and we cannot sit back and wave it through
For Aged and Residential Care
Your challenges are now very public – attracting and retaining staff. We have two pieces in play-
For those covered by the Care and Support legislation – we are now in a full blown pay equity process
For those covered by CAs in the 5 big ARC employers (Oceania, BUPA, Radius, Summerset and Rymans) we are taking on a whole new campaign using what is called pattern bargaining – bargaining the same MM based claims across those 5 employers – pay equity/pay parity, ratios, health and safety, protections for immigrant nurses and so on.
Why those five employers?
Because they dominate the ARC market – they set rates for residents and rates for nurses and caregivers.
They make enormous profits and yet cry poor when it comes to paying their staff more.
In primary health care, we continue to be stuck as we cannot yet achieve either pay parity or a pathway to pay parity. The Minister continually said he is committed to pay parity for this sector but nothing emerges- and all the time this frontline suffers as nurses leave for better wages and new nurses are not attracted.
Te Whatu Ora says that the two recent capitation payments to GPs have enough to pay parity. But that’s not true – and so we campaign onwards and move to action.
Our Plunket nurses are in the same spot. Losing nurses everywhere and failing to attract and retain nurses due to the pay rates.
This situation for primary health must be fixed and fixed once and for all.
Lastly but not least – let’s turn to those working for Māori and iwi providers.
Where the worst pay discrepancies are found?
This situation is a scandal successive govts have been responsible for years for –
- Inadequate funding
- Failure to recognise the additional cultural responsibilities on Māori nurses
- Poor funding models ensuring a lack of confidence in ongoing funding;
- And a lack of concern for Te Tino Rangatiratanga.
This has to stop!
On NZNO’s part we are launching a separate campaign to address this and achieve pay parity plus (the plus being the additional recognition for the cultural knowledge, skills and responsibilities expected of our Māori nurses.
We will build Māori models of organising and will take a different form from normal organising campaigns – but it will be an organising campaign – members working together to win.
And of course, there is a whole lot more to win that I have run out of time to cover.
We need to build a sustainable education and training system that meets NZ workforce needs now and into the future.
And while we fix that – we need to get nursing onto the immigrant Green List – like doctors – to expedite the immigration of nurses to New Zealand.
We need to build career pathways (or staircasing) so health sector workers can see a way ahead if they so choose.
And is there any urgency about all of this – you bet – in twelve months plus time there is a general election and if the govt changes it all becomes so much harder.
In conclusion – I want to talk about respect.
Since my time in NZNO I have felt keenly this issue of respect – or rather lack of respect that is shown to nurses, our HCAs, our midwives, our care and support workers and other NZNO members and their union NZNO.
I know you feel this. You have told me.
Well – that is going to change.
NZNO is not going to sit back any longer –
- and just accept what’s dished out to us
- waiting at the end of the queue
- letting the system and employers trample all over us
- having others set the agenda for our profession. Telling you what is good for you
- And ultimately – being disrespected
That’s finished as of now
NZNO will from now on be respected
We will be respected as –
- the biggest health union
- as the professional and industrial voice of the profession
- but most importantly as the powerful force of 55,000 and growing members
And if your union is respected, then you as members of that union are respected.
And I am sure that is what you want and it is what the people you represent want
But you know it simply doesn’t happen because we want it
It happens because we are prepared to go out and do what needs to be done to win it
That is Maranga Mai
But do you know what the big win will be?
It will be respect – respect for –
- your colleagues
- your profession
- and your ambitions
And in my last question to you – are we going to take this on?
Do we have the strength, the endurance and ultimately the belief?
We believe what we stand for is right and we should be respected for that.
Are we up for winning this?
Are we up for respect?
Because if we are –
We will win it